Hasil untuk "cs.IT"

Menampilkan 20 dari ~2 hasil · dari arXiv, DOAJ

JSON API
arXiv Open Access 2022
The DoF Region of Two-User MIMO Broadcast Channel with Delayed Imperfect-Quality CSIT

Tong Zhang

The channel state information at the transmitter (CSIT) play an important role in the performance of wireless networks. The CSIT model can be delayed and imperfect-quality, since the feedback link has a delay and the channel state information (CSI) feedback has distortion. In this paper, we thus characterize the degrees-of-freedom (DoF) region of the two-user multiple-input multiple-output (MIMO) broadcast channel with delayed imperfect-quality CSIT, where the antenna configurations can be arbitrary. The converse proof of DoF region is based on the enhancement of physically degraded channel. The achievability proof of DoF region is through a novel transmission scheme design, where the duration of each phase and the amount of transmitted symbols are configured based on the imperfect-quality of delayed CSIT. As a result, we show that the DoF region with delayed imperfect-quality CSIT is located between the DoF region with no CSIT and the DoF region with delayed CSIT.

en cs.IT
arXiv Open Access 2020
Information-Theoretic Approximation to Causal Models

Peter Gmeiner

Inferring the causal direction and causal effect between two discrete random variables X and Y from a finite sample is often a crucial problem and a challenging task. However, if we have access to observational and interventional data, it is possible to solve that task. If X is causing Y, then it does not matter if we observe an effect in Y by observing changes in X or by intervening actively on X. This invariance principle creates a link between observational and interventional distributions in a higher dimensional probability space. We embed distributions that originate from samples of X and Y into that higher dimensional space such that the embedded distribution is closest to the distributions that follow the invariance principle, with respect to the relative entropy. This allows us to calculate the best information-theoretic approximation for a given empirical distribution, that follows an assumed underlying causal model. We show that this information-theoretic approximation to causal models (IACM) can be done by solving a linear optimization problem. In particular, by approximating the empirical distribution to a monotonic causal model, we can calculate probabilities of causation. We can also use IACM for causal discovery problems in the bivariate, discrete case. However, experimental results on labeled synthetic data from additive noise models show that our causal discovery approach is lagging behind state-of-the-art approaches because the invariance principle encodes only a necessary condition for causal relations. Nevertheless, for synthetic multiplicative noise data and real-world data, our approach can compete in some cases with alternative methods.

en stat.ML, cs.IT
arXiv Open Access 2019
Beyond Dirty Paper Coding for Multi-Antenna Broadcast Channel with Partial CSIT: A Rate-Splitting Approach

Yijie Mao, Bruno Clerckx

Imperfect Channel State Information at the Transmitter (CSIT) is inevitable in modern wireless communication networks, and results in severe multi-user interference in multi-antenna Broadcast Channel (BC). While the capacity of the multi-antenna (Gaussian) BC with perfect CSIT is known and achieved by Dirty Paper Coding (DPC), the capacity and the capacity-achieving strategy of the multi-antenna BC with imperfect CSIT remain unknown. Conventional approaches therefore rely on applying communication strategies designed for perfect CSIT to the imperfect CSIT setting. In this work, we break this conventional routine and make two major contributions. First, we show that linearly precoded Rate-Splitting (RS), relying on the split of messages into common and private parts and linear precoding at the transmitter, and successive interference cancellation at the receivers, can achieve larger rate regions than DPC in multi-antenna BC with partial CSIT. Second, we propose a novel achievable scheme, denoted as Dirty Paper Coded Rate-Splitting (DPCRS), that relies on RS to split the user messages into common and private parts, and DPC to encode the private parts. We show that the rate region achieved by DPCRS in Multiple-Input Single-Output (MISO) BC with partial CSIT is enlarged beyond that of conventional DPC and that of linearly precoded RS. Gaining benefits from the capability of RS to partially decode the interference and partially treat interference as noise, DPCRS is less sensitive to CSIT inaccuracies, networks loads and user deployments compared with DPC and other existing transmission strategies. The proposed DPCRS acts as a new benchmark and the best-known achievable strategy for multi-antenna BC with partial CSIT.

en cs.IT, eess.SP
arXiv Open Access 2016
Achievable Degrees of Freedom of the K-user MISO Broadcast Channel with Alternating CSIT via Interference Creation-Resurrection

Mohamed Seif, Amr El-Keyi, Mohammed Nafie

Channel state information at the transmitter affects the degrees of freedom of the wireless networks. In this paper, we analyze the DoF for the K-user multiple-input single-output (MISO) broadcast channel (BC) with synergistic alternating channel state information at the transmitter (CSIT). Specifically, the CSIT of each user alternates between three states, namely, perfect CSIT (P), delayed CSIT (D) and no CSIT (N) among different time slots. For the K-user MISO BC, we show that the total achievable degrees of freedom (DoF) are given by $\frac{K^{2}}{2K-1}$ through utilizing the synergistic benefits of CSIT patterns. We compare the achievable DoF with results reported previously in the literature in the case of delayed CSIT and hybrid CSIT models.

en cs.IT
arXiv Open Access 2016
On Storage Allocation in Cache-Enabled Interference Channels with Mixed CSIT

Mohammad Ali Tahmasbi Nejad, Seyed Pooya Shariatpanahi, Babak Hossein Khalaj

Recently, it has been shown that in a cache-enabled interference channel, the storage at the transmit and receive sides are of equal value in terms of Degrees of Freedom (DoF). This is derived by assuming full Channel State Information at the Transmitter (CSIT). In this paper, we consider a more practical scenario, where a training/feedback phase should exist for obtaining CSIT, during which instantaneous channel state is not known to the transmitters. This results in a combination of delayed and current CSIT availability, called mixed CSIT. In this setup, we derive DoF of a cache-enabled interference channel with mixed CSIT, which depends on the memory available at transmit and receive sides as well as the training/feedback phase duration. In contrast to the case of having full CSIT, we prove that, in our setup, the storage at the receive side is more valuable than the one at the transmit side. This is due to the fact that cooperation opportunities granted by transmitters' caches are strongly based on instantaneous CSIT availability. However, multi-casting opportunities provided by receivers' caches are robust to such imperfection.

en cs.IT
arXiv Open Access 2014
On the Degrees-of-freedom of the 3-user MISO Broadcast Channel with Hybrid CSIT

SaiDhiraj Amuru, Ravi Tandon, Shlomo Shamai

The 3-user multiple-input single-output (MISO) broadcast channel (BC) with hybrid channel state information at the transmitter (CSIT) is considered. In this framework, there is perfect and instantaneous CSIT from a subset of users and delayed CSIT from the remaining users. We present new results on the degrees of freedom (DoF) of the 3-user MISO BC with hybrid CSIT. In particular, for the case of 2 transmit antennas, we show that with perfect CSIT from one user and delayed CSIT from the remaining two users, the optimal DoF is 5/3. For the case of 3 transmit antennas and the same hybrid CSIT setting, it is shown that a higher DoF of 9/5 is achievable and this result improves upon the best known bound. Furthermore, with 3 transmit antennas, and the hybrid CSIT setting in which there is perfect CSIT from two users and delayed CSIT from the third one, a novel scheme is presented which achieves 9/4 DoF. Our results also reveal new insights on how to utilize hybrid channel knowledge for multi-user scenarios.

en cs.IT
arXiv Open Access 2014
Distributed Compressive CSIT Estimation and Feedback for FDD Multi-user Massive MIMO Systems

Xiongbin Rao, Vincent K. N. Lau

To fully utilize the spatial multiplexing gains or array gains of massive MIMO, the channel state information must be obtained at the transmitter side (CSIT). However, conventional CSIT estimation approaches are not suitable for FDD massive MIMO systems because of the overwhelming training and feedback overhead. In this paper, we consider multi-user massive MIMO systems and deploy the compressive sensing (CS) technique to reduce the training as well as the feedback overhead in the CSIT estimation. The multi-user massive MIMO systems exhibits a hidden joint sparsity structure in the user channel matrices due to the shared local scatterers in the physical propagation environment. As such, instead of naively applying the conventional CS to the CSIT estimation, we propose a distributed compressive CSIT estimation scheme so that the compressed measurements are observed at the users locally, while the CSIT recovery is performed at the base station jointly. A joint orthogonal matching pursuit recovery algorithm is proposed to perform the CSIT recovery, with the capability of exploiting the hidden joint sparsity in the user channel matrices. We analyze the obtained CSIT quality in terms of the normalized mean absolute error, and through the closed-form expressions, we obtain simple insights into how the joint channel sparsity can be exploited to improve the CSIT recovery performance.

arXiv Open Access 2013
Optimal DoF Region of the Two-User MISO-BC with General Alternating CSIT

Jinyuan Chen, Petros Elia

In the setting of the time-selective two-user multiple-input single-output (MISO) broadcast channel (BC), recent work by Tandon et al. considered the case where - in the presence of error-free delayed channel state information at the transmitter (delayed CSIT) - the current CSIT for the channel of user 1 and of user 2, alternate between the two extreme states of perfect current CSIT and of no current CSIT. Motivated by the problem of having limited-capacity feedback links which may not allow for perfect CSIT, as well as by the need to utilize any available partial CSIT, we here deviate from this `all-or-nothing' approach and proceed - again in the presence of error-free delayed CSIT - to consider the general setting where current CSIT now alternates between any two qualities. Specifically for $I_1$ and $I_2$ denoting the high-SNR asymptotic rates-of-decay of the mean-square error of the CSIT estimates for the channel of user~1 and of user~2 respectively, we consider the case where $I_1,I_2 \in\{γ,α\}$ for any two positive current-CSIT quality exponents $γ,α$. In a fast-fading setting where we consider communication over any number of coherence periods, and where each CSIT state $I_1I_2$ is present for a fraction $λ_{I_1I_2}$ of this total duration, we focus on the symmetric case of $λ_{αγ}=λ_{γα}$, and derive the optimal degrees-of-freedom (DoF) region. The result, which is supported by novel communication protocols, naturally incorporates the aforementioned `Perfect current' vs. `No current' setting by limiting $I_1,I_2\in\{0,1\}$. Finally, motivated by recent interest in frequency correlated channels with unmatched CSIT, we also analyze the setting where there is no delayed CSIT.

en cs.IT
arXiv Open Access 2013
On the DoF Region of the K-user MISO Broadcast Channel with Hybrid CSIT

Kaniska Mohanty, Mahesh K. Varanasi

An outer bound for the degrees of freedom (DoF) region of the K-user multiple-input single-output (MISO) broadcast channel (BC) is developed under the hybrid channel state information at transmitter (CSIT) model, in which the transmitter has instantaneous CSIT of channels to a subset of the receivers and delayed CSIT of channels to the rest of the receivers. For the 3-user MISO BC, when the transmitter has instantaneous CSIT of the channel to one receiver and delayed CSIT of channels to the other two, two new communication schemes are designed, which are able to achieve the DoF tuple of $\left(1,\frac{1}{3},\frac{1}{3}\right)$, with a sum DoF of $\frac{5}{3}$, that is greater than the sum DoF achievable only with delayed CSIT. Another communication scheme showing the benefit of the alternating CSIT model is also developed, to obtain the DoF tuple of $\left(1,\frac{4}{9},\frac{4}{9}\right)$ for the 3-user MISO BC.

en cs.IT
arXiv Open Access 2013
On the Fundamental Feedback-vs-Performance Tradeoff over the MISO-BC with Imperfect and Delayed CSIT

Jinyuan Chen, Sheng Yang, Petros Elia

This work considers the multiuser multiple-input single-output (MISO) broadcast channel (BC), where a transmitter with M antennas transmits information to K single-antenna users, and where - as expected - the quality and timeliness of channel state information at the transmitter (CSIT) is imperfect. Motivated by the fundamental question of how much feedback is necessary to achieve a certain performance, this work seeks to establish bounds on the tradeoff between degrees-of-freedom (DoF) performance and CSIT feedback quality. Specifically, this work provides a novel DoF region outer bound for the general K-user MISO BC with partial current CSIT, which naturally bridges the gap between the case of having no current CSIT (only delayed CSIT, or no CSIT) and the case with full CSIT. The work then characterizes the minimum CSIT feedback that is necessary for any point of the sum DoF, which is optimal for the case with M >= K, and the case with M=2, K=3.

en cs.IT
arXiv Open Access 2013
Secure Degrees of Freedom of MIMO X-Channels with Output Feedback and Delayed CSIT

Abdellatif Zaidi, Zohaib Hassan Awan, Shlomo Shamai et al.

We investigate the problem of secure transmission over a two-user multi-input multi-output (MIMO) X-channel in which channel state information is provided with one-unit delay to both transmitters (CSIT), and each receiver feeds back its channel output to a different transmitter. We refer to this model as MIMO X-channel with asymmetric output feedback and delayed CSIT. The transmitters are equipped with M-antennas each, and the receivers are equipped with N-antennas each. For this model, accounting for both messages at each receiver, we characterize the optimal sum secure degrees of freedom (SDoF) region. We show that, in presence of asymmetric output feedback and delayed CSIT, the sum SDoF region of the MIMO X-channel is same as the SDoF region of a two-user MIMO BC with 2M-antennas at the transmitter, N-antennas at each receiver and delayed CSIT. This result shows that, upon availability of asymmetric output feedback and delayed CSIT, there is no performance loss in terms of sum SDoF due to the distributed nature of the transmitters. Next, we show that this result also holds if only output feedback is conveyed to the transmitters, but in a symmetric manner, i.e., each receiver feeds back its output to both transmitters and no CSIT. We also study the case in which only asymmetric output feedback is provided to the transmitters, i.e., without CSIT, and derive a lower bound on the sum SDoF for this model. Furthermore, we specialize our results to the case in which there are no security constraints. In particular, similar to the setting with security constraints, we show that the optimal sum DoF region of the (M,M,N,N)--MIMO X-channel with asymmetric output feedback and delayed CSIT is same as the DoF region of a two-user MIMO BC with 2M-antennas at the transmitter, N-antennas at each receiver, and delayed CSIT. We illustrate our results with some numerical examples.

arXiv Open Access 2012
The Degrees of Freedom Region of the MIMO Interference Channel with Hybrid CSIT

Kaniska Mohanty, Chinmay S. Vaze, Mahesh K. Varanasi

The degrees of freedom (DoF) region of the two-user MIMO (multiple-input multiple-output) interference channel is established under a new model termed as hybrid CSIT. In this model, one transmitter has delayed channel state information (CSI) and the other transmitter has instantaneous CSIT, of incoming channel matrices at the respective unpaired receivers, and neither transmitter has any knowledge of the incoming channel matrices of its respective paired receiver. The DoF region for hybrid CSIT, and consequently that of $2\times2\times3^{5}$ CSIT models, is completely characterized, and a new achievable scheme based on a combination of transmit beamforming and retrospective interference alignment is developed. Conditions are obtained on the numbers of antennas at each of the four terminals such that the DoF region under hybrid CSIT is equal to that under (a) global and instantaneous CSIT and (b) global and delayed CSIT, with the remaining cases resulting in a DoF region with hybrid CSIT that lies somewhere in between the DoF regions under the instantaneous and delayed CSIT settings. Further synergistic benefits accruing from switching between the two hybrid CSIT models are also explored.

en cs.IT
arXiv Open Access 2012
MISO Broadcast Channel with Delayed and Evolving CSIT

Jinyuan Chen, Petros Elia

The work considers the two-user MISO broadcast channel with gradual and delayed accumulation of channel state information at the transmitter (CSIT), and addresses the question of how much feedback is necessary, and when, in order to achieve a certain degrees-of-freedom (DoF) performance. Motivated by limited-capacity feedback links that may not immediately convey perfect CSIT, and focusing on the block fading scenario, we consider a progressively increasing CSIT quality as time progresses across the coherence period (T channel uses - evolving current CSIT), or at any time after (delayed CSIT). Specifically, for any set of feedback quality exponents a_t, t=1,...,T, describing the high-SNR rates-of-decay of the mean square error of the current CSIT estimates at time t<=T (during the coherence period), the work describes the optimal DOF region in several different evolving CSIT settings, including the setting with perfect delayed CSIT, the asymmetric setting where the quality of feedback differs from user to user, as well as considers the DoF region in the presence of a imperfect delayed CSIT corresponding to having a limited number of overall feedback bits. These results are supported by novel multi-phase precoding schemes that utilize gradually improving CSIT. The approach here naturally incorporates different settings such as the perfect-delayed CSIT setting of Maddah-Ali and Tse, the imperfect current CSIT setting of Yang et al. and of Gou and Jafar, the asymmetric setting of Maleki et al., as well as the not-so-delayed CSIT setting of Lee and Heath.

en cs.IT
arXiv Open Access 2012
Optimal Use of Current and Outdated Channel State Information - Degrees of Freedom of the MISO BC with Mixed CSIT

Tiangao Gou, Syed A. Jafar

We consider a multiple-input-single-output (MISO) broadcast channel with mixed channel state information at the transmitter (CSIT) that consists of imperfect current CSIT and perfect outdated CSIT. Recent work by Kobayashi et al. presented a scheme which exploits both imperfect current CSIT and perfect outdated CSIT and achieves higher degrees of freedom (DoF) than possible with only imperfect current CSIT or only outdated CSIT individually. In this work, we further improve the achievable DoF in this setting by incorporating additional private messages, and provide a tight information theoretic DoF outer bound, thereby identifying the DoF optimal use of mixed CSIT. The new result is stronger even in the original setting of only delayed CSIT, because it allows us to remove the restricting assumption of statistically equivalent fading for all users.

en cs.IT
arXiv Open Access 2012
Imperfect Delayed CSIT can be as Useful as Perfect Delayed CSIT: DoF Analysis and Constructions for the BC

Jinyuan Chen, Petros Elia

In the setting of the two-user broadcast channel, where a two-antenna transmitter communicates information to two single-antenna receivers, recent work by Maddah-Ali and Tse has shown that perfect knowledge of delayed channel state information at the transmitter (perfect delayed CSIT) can be useful, even in the absence of any knowledge of current CSIT. Similar benefits of perfect delayed CSIT were revealed in recent work by Kobayashi et al., Yang et al., and Gou and Jafar, which extended the above to the case of perfect delayed CSIT and imperfect current CSIT. The work here considers the general problem of communicating, over the aforementioned broadcast channel, with imperfect delayed and imperfect current CSIT, and reveals that even substantially degraded and imperfect delayed-CSIT is in fact sufficient to achieve the aforementioned gains previously associated to perfect delayed CSIT. The work proposes novel multi-phase broadcasting schemes that properly utilize knowledge of imperfect delayed and imperfect current CSIT, to match in many cases the optimal degrees-of-freedom (DoF) region achieved with perfect delayed CSIT. In addition to the theoretical limits and explicitly constructed precoders, the work applies towards gaining practical insight as to when it is worth improving CSIT quality.

en cs.IT
arXiv Open Access 2012
On the Synergistic Benefits of Alternating CSIT for the MISO BC

Ravi Tandon, Syed A. Jafar, Shlomo Shamai et al.

The degrees of freedom (DoF) of the two-user multiple-input single-output (MISO) broadcast channel (BC) are studied under the assumption that the form, I_i, i=1,2, of the channel state information at the transmitter (CSIT) for each user's channel can be either perfect (P), delayed (D) or not available (N), i.e., I_1 and I_2 can take values of either P, D or N, and therefore the overall CSIT can alternate between the 9 resulting states, each state denoted as I_1I_2. The fraction of time associated with CSIT state I_1I_2 is denoted by the parameter λ_{I_1I_2} and it is assumed throughout that λ_{I_1I_2}=λ_{I_2I_1}, i.e., λ_{PN}=λ_{NP}, λ_{PD}=λ_{DP}, λ_{DN}=λ_{ND}. Under this assumption of symmetry, the main contribution of this paper is a complete characterization of the DoF region of the two user MISO BC with alternating CSIT. Surprisingly, the DoF region is found to depend only on the marginal probabilities (λ_P, λ_D,λ_N)=(\sum_{I_2}λ_{PI_2},\sum_{I_2}λ_{DI_2}, \sum_{I_2}λ_{NI_2}), I_2\in {P,D,N}, which represent the fraction of time that any given user (e.g., user 1) is associated with perfect, delayed, or no CSIT, respectively. As a consequence, the DoF region with all 9 CSIT states, \mathcal{D}(λ_{I_1I_2}:I_1,I_2\in{P,D,N}), is the same as the DoF region with only 3 CSIT states \mathcal{D}(λ_{PP}, λ_{DD}, λ_{NN}), under the same marginal distribution of CSIT states, i.e., (λ_{PP}, λ_{DD},λ_{NN})=(λ_P,λ_D,λ_N). The results highlight the synergistic benefits of alternating CSIT and the tradeoffs between various forms of CSIT for any given DoF value.

en cs.IT
arXiv Open Access 2012
Degrees-of-Freedom Region of the MISO Broadcast Channel with General Mixed-CSIT

Jinyuan Chen, Petros Elia

In the setting of the two-user broadcast channel, recent work by Maddah-Ali and Tse has shown that knowledge of prior channel state information at the transmitter (CSIT) can be useful, even in the absence of any knowledge of current CSIT. Very recent work by Kobayashi et al., Yang et al., and Gou and Jafar, extended this to the case where, instead of no current CSIT knowledge, the transmitter has partial knowledge, and where under a symmetry assumption, the quality of this knowledge is identical for the different users' channels. Motivated by the fact that in multiuser settings, the quality of CSIT feedback may vary across different links, we here generalize the above results to the natural setting where the current CSIT quality varies for different users' channels. For this setting we derive the optimal degrees-of-freedom (DoF) region, and provide novel multi-phase broadcast schemes that achieve this optimal region. Finally this generalization incorporates and generalizes the corresponding result in Maleki et al. which considered the broadcast channel with one user having perfect CSIT and the other only having prior CSIT.

en cs.IT
arXiv Open Access 2012
Interference Alignment with Incomplete CSIT Sharing

Paul de Kerret, David Gesbert

In this work, we study the impact of having only incomplete channel state information at the transmitters (CSIT) over the feasibility of interference alignment (IA) in a K-user MIMO interference channel (IC). Incompleteness of CSIT refers to the perfect knowledge at each transmitter (TX) of only a sub-matrix of the global channel matrix, where the sub-matrix is specific to each TX. This paper investigates the notion of IA feasibility for CSIT configurations being as incomplete as possible, as this leads to feedback overhead reductions in practice. We distinguish between antenna configurations where (i) removing a single antenna makes IA unfeasible, referred to as tightly-feasible settings, and (ii) cases where extra antennas are available, referred to as super-feasible settings. We show conditions for which IA is feasible in strictly incomplete CSIT scenarios, even in tightly-feasible settings. For such cases, we provide a CSIT allocation policy preserving IA feasibility while reducing significantly the amount of CSIT required. For super-feasible settings, we develop a heuristic CSIT allocation algorithm which exploits the additional antennas to further reduce the size of the CSIT allocation. As a byproduct of our approach, a simple and intuitive algorithm for testing feasibility of single stream IA is provided.

en cs.IT
arXiv Open Access 2012
Minimum CSIT to achieve Maximum Degrees of Freedom for the MISO BC

Ravi Tandon, Syed A. Jafar, Shlomo Shamai

Channel state information at the transmitter (CSIT) is a key ingredient in realizing the multiplexing gain provided by distributed MIMO systems. For a downlink multiple-input single output (MISO) broadcast channel, with M antennas at the transmitters and K single antenna receivers, the maximum multiplexing gain or the maximum degrees of freedom (DoF) is min(M,K). The optimal DoF of min(M,K) is achievable if the transmitter has access to perfect, instantaneous CSIT from all receivers. In this paper, we pose the question that what is minimum amount of CSIT required per user in order to achieve the maximum DoF of min(M,K). By minimum amount of CSIT per user, we refer to the minimum fraction of time that the transmitter has access to perfect and instantaneous CSIT from a user. Through a novel converse proof and an achievable scheme, it is shown that the minimum fraction of time, perfect CSIT is required per user in order to achieve the DoF of min(M,K) is given by min(M,K)/K.

en cs.IT
arXiv Open Access 2011
Degrees of Freedom Region of the MIMO Interference Channel with Output Feedback and Delayed CSIT

Ravi Tandon, Soheil Mohajer, H. Vincent Poor et al.

The two-user multiple-input multiple-output (MIMO) interference channel (IC) with arbitrary number of antennas at each terminal is considered and the degrees of freedom (DoF) region is characterized in the presence of noiseless channel output feedback from each receiver to its respective transmitter and availability of delayed channel state information at the transmitters (CSIT). It is shown that having output feedback and delayed CSIT can strictly enlarge the DoF region of the MIMO IC when compared to the case in which only delayed CSIT is present. The proposed coding schemes that achieve the corresponding DoF region with feedback and delayed CSIT utilize both resources, i.e., feedback and delayed CSIT in a non-trivial manner. It is also shown that the DoF region with local feedback and delayed CSIT is equal to the DoF region with global feedback and delayed CSIT, i.e., local feedback and delayed CSIT is equivalent to global feedback and delayed CSIT from the perspective of the degrees of freedom region. The converse is proved for a stronger setting in which the channels to the two receivers need not be statistically equivalent.