Writing literature reviews with AI: principles, hurdles and some lessons learned
Saadi Lahlou, Annabelle Gouttebroze, Atrina Oraee
et al.
We qualitatively compared literature reviews produced with varying degrees of AI assistance. The same LLM, given the same corpus of 280 papers but different selections, produced dramatically different reviews, from mainstream and politically neutral to critical and post-colonial, though neither orientation was intended. LLM outputs always appear at first glance to be well written, well informed and thought out, but closer reading reveals gaps, biases and lack of depth. Our comparison of six versions shows a series of pitfalls and suggests precautions necessary when using AI assistance to make a literature review. Main issues are: (1) The bias of ignorance (you do not know what you do not get) in the selection of relevant papers. (2) Alignment and digital sycophancy: commercial AI models slavishly take you further in the direction they understand you give them, reinforcing biases. (3) Mainstreaming: because of their statistical nature, LLM productions tend to favor mainstream perspectives and content; in our case there was only 20% overlap between paper selections by humans and the LLM. (4) Limited capacity for creative restructuring, with vague and ambiguous statements. (5) Lack of critical perspective, coming from distant reading and political correctness. Most pitfalls can be addressed by prompting, but only if the user knows the domain well enough to detect them. There is a paradox: producing a good AI-assisted review requires expertise that comes from reading the literature, which is precisely what AI was meant to reduce. Overall, AI can improve the span and quality of the review, but the gain of time is not as massive as one would expect, and a press-button strategy leaving AI to do the work is a recipe for disaster. We conclude with recommendations for those who write, or assess, such LLM-augmented reviews.
Ontetepehuac, onchachahuayac Il a semé, il a répandu des pierres précieuses
José Contel, Fiona Pugliese
Latin America. Spanish America, French literature - Italian literature - Spanish literature - Portuguese literature
Microwave Engineering of Tunable Spin Interactions with Superconducting Qubits
Kui Zhao, Ziting Wang, Yu Liu
et al.
Quantum simulation has emerged as a powerful framework for investigating complex many - body phenomena. A key requirement for emulating these dynamics is the realization of fully controllable quantum systems enabling various spin interactions. Yet, quantum simulators remain constrained in the types of attainable interactions. Here we demonstrate experimental realization of multiple microwave - engineered spin interactions in superconducting quantum circuits. By precisely controlling the native XY interaction and microwave drives, we achieve tunable spin Hamiltonians including: (i) XYZ spin models with continuously adjustable parameters, (ii) transverse - field Ising systems, and (iii) Dzyaloshinskii - Moriya interacting systems. Our work expands the toolbox for analogue - digital quantum simulation, enabling exploration of a wide range of exotic quantum spin models.
Trust and Trustworthiness from Human-Centered Perspective in HRI -- A Systematic Literature Review
Debora Firmino de Souza, Sonia Sousa, Kadri Kristjuhan-Ling
et al.
The Industry 5.0 transition highlights EU efforts to design intelligent devices that can work alongside humans to enhance human capabilities, and such vision aligns with user preferences and needs to feel safe while collaborating with such systems take priority. This demands a human-centric research vision and requires a societal and educational shift in how we perceive technological advancements. To better understand this perspective, we conducted a systematic literature review focusing on understanding how trust and trustworthiness can be key aspects of supporting this move towards Industry 5.0. This review aims to overview the most common methodologies and measurements and collect insights about barriers and facilitators for fostering trustworthy HRI. After a rigorous quality assessment following the Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines, using rigorous inclusion criteria and screening by at least two reviewers, 34 articles were included in the review. The findings underscores the significance of trust and safety as foundational elements for promoting secure and trustworthy human-machine cooperation. Confirm that almost 30% of the revised articles do not present a definition of trust, which can be problematic as this lack of conceptual clarity can undermine research efforts in addressing this problem from a central perspective. It highlights that the choice of domain and area of application should influence the choice of methods and approaches to fostering trust in HRI, as those choices can significantly affect user preferences and their perceptions and assessment of robot capabilities. Additionally, this lack of conceptual clarity can be a potential barrier to fostering trust in HRI and explains the sometimes contradictory findings or choice of methods and instruments used to investigate trust in robots and other autonomous systems in the literature.
Context in object detection: a systematic literature review
Mahtab Jamali, Paul Davidsson, Reza Khoshkangini
et al.
Context is an important factor in computer vision as it offers valuable information to clarify and analyze visual data. Utilizing the contextual information inherent in an image or a video can improve the precision and effectiveness of object detectors. For example, where recognizing an isolated object might be challenging, context information can improve comprehension of the scene. This study explores the impact of various context-based approaches to object detection. Initially, we investigate the role of context in object detection and survey it from several perspectives. We then review and discuss the most recent context-based object detection approaches and compare them. Finally, we conclude by addressing research questions and identifying gaps for further studies. More than 265 publications are included in this survey, covering different aspects of context in different categories of object detection, including general object detection, video object detection, small object detection, camouflaged object detection, zero-shot, one-shot, and few-shot object detection. This literature review presents a comprehensive overview of the latest advancements in context-based object detection, providing valuable contributions such as a thorough understanding of contextual information and effective methods for integrating various context types into object detection, thus benefiting researchers.
“Poetry slam” em Portugal: disputas pós-coloniais
Maria Giulia Pinheiro, Saru Vidal, Cynthia Agra de Brito Neves
The purpose of this paper is to discuss and analyze public posts on the social network Facebook that point to xenophobic opinions about the (i)migrant poetry slam scene in Portugal. These posts reflect the post-colonial attitudes of a historically colonizing country, which is currently experiencing a cultural identity crisis that oscillates between Lusotropicalist and Eurocentric ideology, and whose economic, racial and gender discrimination is still present. We will therefore look at poetry slam in Portugal in the light of post-colonial, identity and social disputes.
French literature - Italian literature - Spanish literature - Portuguese literature, Social sciences (General)
Automated Literature Review Using NLP Techniques and LLM-Based Retrieval-Augmented Generation
Nurshat Fateh Ali, Md. Mahdi Mohtasim, Shakil Mosharrof
et al.
This research presents and compares multiple approaches to automate the generation of literature reviews using several Natural Language Processing (NLP) techniques and retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) with a Large Language Model (LLM). The ever-increasing number of research articles provides a huge challenge for manual literature review. It has resulted in an increased demand for automation. Developing a system capable of automatically generating the literature reviews from only the PDF files as input is the primary objective of this research work. The effectiveness of several Natural Language Processing (NLP) strategies, such as the frequency-based method (spaCy), the transformer model (Simple T5), and retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) with Large Language Model (GPT-3.5-turbo), is evaluated to meet the primary objective. The SciTLDR dataset is chosen for this research experiment and three distinct techniques are utilized to implement three different systems for auto-generating the literature reviews. The ROUGE scores are used for the evaluation of all three systems. Based on the evaluation, the Large Language Model GPT-3.5-turbo achieved the highest ROUGE-1 score, 0.364. The transformer model comes in second place and spaCy is at the last position. Finally, a graphical user interface is created for the best system based on the large language model.
« L’Italie est faite, il reste à faire l’italien ! »
Stefano Magni
Au lendemain de l’unification politique de la péninsule, les Italiens n’avaient pas une langue commune. Le taux d’analphabètes était très élevé et le pourcentage d’italophones très faible. Face à cette situation dramatique, le Gouvernement italien promut l’action d’une commission ministérielle. A. Manzoni, qui dirigeait ce projet, décida de prendre des mesures visant à stimuler dans les autres régions la diffusion du florentin parlé. À l’encontre de ce projet, culturellement artificiel, le linguiste G.I. Ascoli attaqua l’aspect factice de ce programme linguistique, proposant un modèle de développement spontané et homogène de la langue comme aboutissement naturel de la rencontre des dialectes.
Language and Literature, French literature - Italian literature - Spanish literature - Portuguese literature
L'“esodo” dei venezuelani in Colombia. Tra sfide migratorie, processi di pace e ricomposizione dell’ordine sociale
Thea Rossi
The current migratory movement from Venezuela to Colombia is at the heart of a heated debate. This paper aims to focus the attention on the Colombian context, starting from the transition process generated after the internal armed conflict. After that, border dynamics and migration policies will be examined, highlighting how the centrality of the subject order / disorder, social harmony / disharmony has also oriented the construction of the figure of the Venezuelan migrant both politically and in the media, with consequences on the reception and inclusion.
French literature - Italian literature - Spanish literature - Portuguese literature, Social sciences (General)
AI Literature Review Suite
David A. Tovar
The process of conducting literature reviews is often time-consuming and labor-intensive. To streamline this process, I present an AI Literature Review Suite that integrates several functionalities to provide a comprehensive literature review. This tool leverages the power of open access science, large language models (LLMs) and natural language processing to enable the searching, downloading, and organizing of PDF files, as well as extracting content from articles. Semantic search queries are used for data retrieval, while text embeddings and summarization using LLMs present succinct literature reviews. Interaction with PDFs is enhanced through a user-friendly graphical user interface (GUI). The suite also features integrated programs for bibliographic organization, interaction and query, and literature review summaries. This tool presents a robust solution to automate and optimize the process of literature review in academic and industrial research.
Macroeconomic Effects of Inflation Targeting: A Survey of the Empirical Literature
Goran Petrevski
This paper surveys the empirical literature of inflation targeting. The main findings from our review are the following: there is robust empirical evidence that larger and more developed countries are more likely to adopt the IT regime; the introduction of this regime is conditional on previous disinflation, greater exchange rate flexibility, central bank independence, and higher level of financial development; the empirical evidence has failed to provide convincing evidence that IT itself may serve as an effective tool for stabilizing inflation expectations and for reducing inflation persistence; the empirical research focused on advanced economies has failed to provide convincing evidence on the beneficial effects of IT on inflation performance, while there is some evidence that the gains from the IT regime may have been more prevalent in the emerging market economies; there is not convincing evidence that IT is associated with either higher output growth or lower output variability; the empirical research suggests that IT may have differential effects on exchange-rate volatility in advanced economies versus EMEs; although the empirical evidence on the impact of IT on fiscal policy is quite limited, it supports the idea that IT indeed improves fiscal discipline; the empirical support to the proposition that IT is associated with lower disinflation costs seems to be rather weak. Therefore, the accumulated empirical literature implies that IT does not produce superior macroeconomic benefits in comparison with the alternative monetary strategies or, at most, they are quite modest.
Evolution of ESG-focused DLT Research: An NLP Analysis of the Literature
Walter Hernandez Cruz, Kamil Tylinski, Alastair Moore
et al.
Distributed Ledger Technology (DLT) faces increasing environmental scrutiny, particularly concerning the energy consumption of the Proof of Work (PoW) consensus mechanism and broader Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) issues. However, existing systematic literature reviews of DLT rely on limited analyses of citations, abstracts, and keywords, failing to fully capture the field's complexity and ESG concerns. We address these challenges by analyzing the full text of 24,539 publications using Natural Language Processing (NLP) with our manually labeled Named Entity Recognition (NER) dataset of 39,427 entities for DLT. This methodology identified 505 key publications at the DLT/ESG intersection, enabling comprehensive domain analysis. Our combined NLP and temporal graph analysis reveals critical trends in DLT evolution and ESG impacts, including cryptography and peer-to-peer networks research's foundational influence, Bitcoin's persistent impact on research and environmental concerns (a "Lindy effect"), Ethereum's catalytic role on Proof of Stake (PoS) and smart contract adoption, and the industry's progressive shift toward energy-efficient consensus mechanisms. Our contributions include the first DLT-specific NER dataset addressing the scarcity of high-quality labeled NLP data in blockchain research, a methodology integrating NLP and temporal graph analysis for large-scale interdisciplinary literature reviews, and the first NLP-driven literature review focusing on DLT's ESG aspects.
Evaluasi penerapan model pembelajaran inkuiri terbimbing dalam pembelajaran kimia : Suatu tinjauan sistematis literatur
Ainayya Almira, Anisah Rachmawati, Insi Norma Jelita
et al.
The aim of this research is to provide insight to chemistry education teachers and researchers regarding the effectiveness of the guided inquiry learning model and provide direction for further research in this field. The research method used in this article is Systematic Literature Review (SLR), to help compile and evaluate various research related to the guided inquiry learning model. The instrument used in this research is to present the results of a literature review of various articles discussing the application of this model in chemistry learning by exploring the definition, application, strengths, weaknesses and effectiveness of the guided inquiry learning model in chemistry learning. The research results show that the application of this model can be carried out both in the theoretical and practical aspects of chemistry learning. The advantages of the guided inquiry model involve students actively, increase learning independence, and provide students with the opportunity to discuss and find their own answers. Students who study with this model tend to have higher learning achievements. However, there are also disadvantages, such as the time required to implement this model and obstacles in dealing with students who are not yet familiar with this approach.
Ontologies in Digital Twins: A Systematic Literature Review
Erkan Karabulut, Salvatore F. Pileggi, Paul Groth
et al.
Digital Twins (DT) facilitate monitoring and reasoning processes in cyber-physical systems. They have progressively gained popularity over the past years because of intense research activity and industrial advancements. Cognitive Twins is a novel concept, recently coined to refer to the involvement of Semantic Web technology in DTs. Recent studies address the relevance of ontologies and knowledge graphs in the context of DTs, in terms of knowledge representation, interoperability and automatic reasoning. However, there is no comprehensive analysis of how semantic technologies, and specifically ontologies, are utilized within DTs. This Systematic Literature Review (SLR) is based on the analysis of 82 research articles, that either propose or benefit from ontologies with respect to DT. The paper uses different analysis perspectives, including a structural analysis based on a reference DT architecture, and an application-specific analysis to specifically address the different domains, such as Manufacturing and Infrastructure. The review also identifies open issues and possible research directions on the usage of ontologies and knowledge graphs in DTs.
GILDA BONA (COORD.), SEIS TEXTOS DE AUTORAS DEL NEA, RESISTENCIA, CONTEXTO LIBROS, 2021
Genesis Gaczek
Philology. Linguistics, French literature - Italian literature - Spanish literature - Portuguese literature
Drivers' attention detection: a systematic literature review
Luiz G. Véras, Anna K. F. Gomes, Guilherme A. R. Dominguez
et al.
Countless traffic accidents often occur because of the inattention of the drivers. Many factors can contribute to distractions while driving, since objects or events to physiological conditions, as drowsiness and fatigue, do not allow the driver to stay attentive. The technological progress allowed the development and application of many solutions to detect the attention in real situations, promoting the interest of the scientific community in these last years. Commonly, these solutions identify the lack of attention and alert the driver, in order to help her/him to recover the attention, avoiding serious accidents and preserving lives. Our work presents a Systematic Literature Review (SLR) of the methods and criteria used to detect attention of drivers at the wheel, focusing on those methods based on images. As results, 50 studies were selected from the literature on drivers' attention detection, in which 22 contain solutions in the desired context. The results of SLR can be used as a resource in the preparation of new research projects in drivers' attention detection.
Advancing Data Justice Research and Practice: An Integrated Literature Review
David Leslie, Michael Katell, Mhairi Aitken
et al.
The Advancing Data Justice Research and Practice (ADJRP) project aims to widen the lens of current thinking around data justice and to provide actionable resources that will help policymakers, practitioners, and impacted communities gain a broader understanding of what equitable, freedom-promoting, and rights-sustaining data collection, governance, and use should look like in increasingly dynamic and global data innovation ecosystems. In this integrated literature review we hope to lay the conceptual groundwork needed to support this aspiration. The introduction motivates the broadening of data justice that is undertaken by the literature review which follows. First, we address how certain limitations of the current study of data justice drive the need for a re-location of data justice research and practice. We map out the strengths and shortcomings of the contemporary state of the art and then elaborate on the challenges faced by our own effort to broaden the data justice perspective in the decolonial context. The body of the literature review covers seven thematic areas. For each theme, the ADJRP team has systematically collected and analysed key texts in order to tell the critical empirical story of how existing social structures and power dynamics present challenges to data justice and related justice fields. In each case, this critical empirical story is also supplemented by the transformational story of how activists, policymakers, and academics are challenging longstanding structures of inequity to advance social justice in data innovation ecosystems and adjacent areas of technological practice.
Systematic Literature Review of Gender and Software Engineering in Asia
Hironori Washizaki
It is essential to discuss the role, difficulties, and opportunities concerning people of different gender in the field of software engineering research, education, and industry. Although some literature reviews address software engineering and gender, it is still unclear how research and practices in Asia exist for handling gender aspects in software development and engineering. We conducted a systematic literature review to grasp the comprehensive view of gender research and practices in Asia. We analyzed the 32 identified papers concerning countries and publication years among 463 publications. Researchers and practitioners from various organizations actively work on gender research and practices in some countries, including China, India, and Turkey. We identified topics and classified them into seven categories varying from personal mental health and team building to organization. Future research directions include investigating the synergy between (regional) gender aspects and cultural concerns and considering possible contributions and dependency among different topics to have a solid foundation for accelerating further research and getting actionable practices.
El libro mágico de Zenofor: la singularidad del "Valerián de Hungría"
Jesús Duce García
Entre los motivos relacionados con los grimorios o libros mágicos que abundan en el género de los libros de caballerías, el ejemplo que aparece en el Valerián de Hungría representa una singularidad muy destacable. Se trata del libro del sabio Zenofor, posiblemente el objeto fantástico más original creado por el notario valenciano Dionís Clemente, autor de la obra. El libro de Zenofor reúne elementos maravillosos de diversa índole, relacionados, como resulta pertinente, con el sistema probatorio que deben superar los héroes caballerescos. Ahora bien, el poder más inusitado del libro de Zenofor es la capacidad de reproducir imágenes reales de personas que se encuentran en otros lugares, a modo de una conexión visual, simultánea en el tiempo, entre espacios y dimensiones diferentes. Todo lo cual otorga a este increíble objeto el dominio insospechado de la imagen y la palabra.
Language and Literature, French literature - Italian literature - Spanish literature - Portuguese literature
Juana Manso, Escritos de viaje
Stephanie Mailén Bustamante Salvatierra
Bibliographic review of Escritos de viaje, de Juana Manso, Córdoba, Buena Vista, 2019, 120 pp.
Latin America. Spanish America, French literature - Italian literature - Spanish literature - Portuguese literature