Cognitive-Behavioral-Related Prayer Types and Mental Health Relations among Muslim Samples

Psychological and subjective well-being depends on how an individual feels about his/her life and how he/she responds to life events. Individually, the person may unconsciously feel all external events occurring beyond his/her control in his cognitive schemas. Especially considering mental health, the influence of religious beliefs and practices on various components of mental well-being has emerged as one of the most studied topics in the psychology of religion in recent years. Most studies have focused on the role of religion in seeking answers about individuals' search for meaning and their reactions to life events. There is a prevalent finding that prayer plays a constructive role in the lives of individuals faced with life’s difficulties and exposed to stressors. Thus, for scientists over the past few decades, the possible application of the cognitive behavioral framework within the psychology of religion has become a key element of both subjective and psychological well-being. Using theoretical applications as to the relationship between religiosity and mental health, it was appeared that various prayer measures are predominantly derived from Christian religious norms and beliefs. However, non-Christian religions have been mostly disregarded in such inquiries. More specifically, the links between religiosity and mental health among Muslim individuals have been neglected even though there are several forms of religious behavior in Islam that are of great importance to the daily lives of believers. Therefore, the current research aims to investigate the link between different types of Islamic prayer and indicators of well-being using the cognitive-behavioral mechanism among Muslim individuals. An online link was used to recruit participants from many Islamic student communities and several worship places in different cities/regions of England in this study. The online questionnaire composed of six prayer types (obligatory, necessary, voluntarily, supererogatory, supplication, and invocation prayers), six psychological well-being domains (autonomy, environmental mastery, positive relations with others, personal growth, self-acceptance, and purpose in life), and two subjective well-being domains (life satisfaction, and positive and negative affects). The representative sample consisted of 214 participants (female= 145, male= 69), aged between 18 and 66 (M = 27.01, SD = 8.80). The results of the correlational analysis indicated that obligatory (fard) prayer, voluntarily (sunna) prayer, supplication (duʿāʾ) prayer and invocation (dhikr/remembrance of God) prayer have positive relationship with the well-being variables, while no correlation of necessary (wājib) prayer and supererogatory (nawāfil) prayer with any of the well-being variables is appeared. The results of the multiple regression analysis showed that obligatory, voluntarily, and necessary prayers were not predictors of psychological or subjective well-being variables. Although only the type of supererogatory prayer was found to be predictive, the relationship was in the opposite direction. In addition, the supplication prayer accounted for the unique variance in predicting the 1 This article is the final version of an earlier announcement called “Religion and Well-being: Applying a Cognitive-Behavioral Framework among Muslims”, not previously printed, but orally presented at a symposium called “The IAPR Conference on Culture, Context and Existential Challenges (21-24 August 2017, Hamar/Norway)”, the content of which has now been developed and partially changed. This article is extracted from doctorate dissertation entitled “Prayer Types and Their Associations with Mental and Psychophysiological Health”, (Ph.D. Dissertation, University of Leicester, Leicester, UK), which I completed on February 22, 2019. The researcher Fatümetül Zehra Güldaş is delighted to state that her doctoral studies were funded by the Republic of Turkish Ministry of National Education during her education abroad./ Bu makale, The IAPR Kültür, Bağlam ve Varoluşsal Zorluklar Konferansı (21-24 Ağustos 2017, Norveç/Hamar)'nda sözlü olarak sunulan ve basılmayan “Din ve İyi Oluş Hali: Müslümanlar Arasında Bilişsel-Davranışsal Bir Çerçevenin Uygulanması” adlı tebliğin içeriği geliştirilerek ve kısmen değiştirilerek üretilmiş halidir. Bu makale, 22 Şubat 2019 tarihinde tamamladığım Prayer Types and Their Associations with Mental and Psychophysiological Health başlıklı doktora tezimden üretilerek hazırlanmıştır (Ph.D. Dissertation, University of Leicester, Leicester, UK). Araştırmacı Fatümetül Zehra Güldaş, yurtdışındaki eğitimi sırasında doktora çalışmalarının T.C. Milli Eğitim Bakanlığı tarafından finanse edildiğini belirtmekten mutluluk duyar. Fatümetül Zehra Güldaş. Müslüman Örneklemler Arasında Bilişsel-Davranışla ... | 439 https://dergipark.org.tr/tr/pub/cuid psychological well-being scores, while the invocation prayer accounted for the unique variance in predicting subjective well-being. In light of James and Wells’ cognitive and behavioral models, the present study has identified only the types of supplication and invocation prayer as important factors that have a positive effect for individuals in providing psychological support for them. Therefore, the presented data suggest that people are more like to have better psychological and subjective well-being when their prayers take the form of a supplication prayer and invocation prayer in which they rely on God for guidance and support and refresh their thinking through feeling God’s presence. As can be seen from the present findings, it is important to consider the applicability of belief structures in specific community settings. Here, both the theoretical framework and practical direction can contribute to an understanding being held as to the relationship between Muslim prayer types and mental well-being and provides guidance for health practitioners regarding how different prayer models can lead individuals to have better well-being.